Selling Baseball Cards & Memorabilia

collageSince 1992, American Legends has strived to provide baseball card and memorabilia collectors with the finest selection of items in the NY area.

With a selection of baseball single cards stretching back to the early 1900s, the store has cultivated a very loyal customer base of vintage card buyers.

American Legends is well stocked in the stars of the 1950s (Willie, Mickey & The Duke), 1960s (Aaron, Clemente & Koufax), 1970s (Reggie Jackson, Munson & Seaver), 1980s (Gwynn, Mattingly & Ripken) as well as of today (Arod, Jeter, & Wright). The store also boasts an impressive inventory of Goudeys, Play Balls, Diamond Stars and Tobacco cards as well as a full showcase of game-used jersey and certified autographed cards.

Looking for an elusive set? American Legends carries Topps factory sets from the current year back to the late 1980s and frequently has complete Topps sets back to the 1960s.

Along with our massive inventory of single cards and sets, American Legends carries almost every new release from Topps, Panini, TriStar and Upper Deck. All of your favorite unopened packs and boxes are here from Exquisite to Triple Threads, from Elite to Bowman Chrome, from SPX to Prizm.


sell1Looking for a gift for that special someone? American Legends is fully stocked with autographed memorabilia. Whether its for a Yankees fan or Mets fan (or even a Red Sox fan), current or retired, we have what you are looking for. Our autographed baseball and photo inventory includes the likes of DiMaggio, Jeter, Seaver, Mays, Yastrzemski, Ted Williams, Pujols & even Babe Ruth. Concerned about authenticity? So are we. Thats why our autographed items are from our own in-store player appearances as well as items that we witnessed being signed. sell2We also sell items from reputable sources including Upper Deck Authenticated (UDA), Mounted Memories and Steiner Sports. Vintage items are authenticated by James Spence (JSA) or by PSA/DNA.

Of course, no full-service store would be complete without a full line of collecting supplies. American Legends has a vast array of items to care for your collectibles including Ultra Pro card binders, plastic sheets, cardboard and acrylic storage boxes, top-loaders, one-touch holders and glass and acrylic display cases for baseballs, bats and helmets. We even offer custom framing for your prized collectibles.

The bottom line is, if youre looking for baseball cards and memorabilia, visit American Legends today.