’70s football cards are trending, and if you want to sell them, you must act at the right time. To sell like an expert, you’ll need to research cards and selling options or platforms. American Legends can help you navigate the process if you’re ready to send some players to the bench for a good, fair cost.
According to Yahoo Finance, the sports trading card industry was valued at over 12 billion USD in 2023. Football trading cards have given people (from all around the globe) an interesting hobby to tackle.
If you’ve got a good collection of 60s or 70s football cards but want to get rid of a few items, American Legends can help. Mark Rubin, of American Legends, has been assisting New York area collectors for over 40 years. After following expert selling tips, you’ll be ready to meet us at the table to discuss your cards in detail.
Get Your 70s Football Cards in Good Hands with 5 Tips
Psychology Today found that collections provide people with emotional benefits and stress reduction. Finding 70s collectible cards can be a fulfilling experience, but over time, you might reassess some items.
If you’re searching for ways to increase card sales, there are a few steps you can take to gain momentum.
1. Assess Your Collection & Find a Niche
The football card-selling industry is large and overwhelming when you don’t focus on niche markets. To effectively sell your 70s football cards, you’ll want to identify which cards you own that are the rarest.
By focusing on the 70s, you can attract buyers looking for vintage pieces. When you highlight the time frame of football cards, it can help indicate worth to potential buyers. Take a look at your collection to pull out the cards in mint condition or that seem valuable.
2. Carefully Consider Selling Platforms
Depending on who you ask, online platforms or in-person are the best ways to sell football cards. If you’re having difficulty selling in your area, the internet can help gain attention.
Auction sites are popular, but unfortunately, many leave dissatisfied with their transactions. With American Legends, you’ll get a fair and honest price that reflects industry trends.
Many of our customers appreciate the in-person opportunity to sell. Not only does it make the transaction more personal, but it also exposes you to more knowledge.
3. Conduct Thorough Research
After identifying the key players in your collection, you’ll want to research a few things about your cards. Neglecting to research cards before selling could result in you getting less money for your cards than they’re worth.
Here are a few things to look up:
- Player record & highlights
- Official age of card
- Current market value
It can also help to sell certain cards in groups or multiples. This will attract potential buyers who want a complete collection, without having to visit so many sellers.
4. Monitor the Market
If you want to maximize football card profits, you must sell at the right time. Timing is everything with collectibles, and you can benefit from a little bit of patience.
Selling a large collection can be intimidating to certain buyers. UBS data shows that collectors estimate collections at 10% or greater of net worth. If your card collection is too large to bring into our shop, we can come to you! You can schedule an appointment with Mark to get started.
5. Work with a Reputable Buyer
Since 1992, American Legends has been keeping football and other athletes from being forgotten. The visionaries on trading cards paved the way for current players and have inspired people globally.
Working with American Legends can save you time and help you maximize football card valuations. Our team is different from auction houses, which can take a long time to finalize transactions and come with various fees.
The American Legends process can take as little as an hour or less. If we’re interested in your 70s collectible cards, we can take a look at what you have and potentially give an offer. Within a short time you could be walking away with more money in your wallet!
US and Canadian residents can sell to American Legends, even if they aren’t nearby. After a quick call, we will explain the process of getting profits.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is It Better to Sell Outright or Auction Cards?
Auction sites can expose you to some interesting characters, and it’ll likely take a while for you to get money for your cards. By selling cards outright, you can feel confident about the final sale price of the item and focus on the next search.American Legends has a smooth process and consistent standards, much less stressful than auctions.
Are Football & Other Sports Cards from the 70s Worth Much?
High-grade 70s cards can be difficult to collect, but if you have one, it could be worth more than you realize. PSA 9s and 10s are the most valuable cards. Whether your cards are graded or not, we can purchase them at a fair cost.
What Factors Contribute to the Value of Football Cards?
Regarding old football cards, the age of printing isn’t always enough to make a profit from them. The rarity, condition, and valuable players are the greatest factors for determining a reasonable sale cost.
Which Football Cards Are Currently Popular?
Although some newer editions from the 2020s are trending, many of the specialty cards from the 70s hold a greater rank. Here is a list we put together, showing the 10 most expensive cards to ever be sold. You can work with our team at American Legends to discover hidden gems in your collection or to learn more!
Let’s Talk 1970s Football
Don’t let your 70s football cards continue to collect dust! American Legends, located in NYC, is your one-stop shop for collectibles.
At American Legends, we work with integrity and are an Authorized Upper Deck Diamond Dealer. Tell us about your collection, and we’ll ensure the cards are cared for and that you get a fair price. Our inventory and unique sports cards in the Greater Westchester area has contributed to a strong reputation in New York.
To discover more about new and vintage sports cards, visit our team at American Legends. Contact Mark Rubin at (914) 725-2225 or submit an online inquiry!

